A short about my only experience with Progressive. I hit a kid who was in the wrong lane making a left, and then he abruptly turned right across my lane....no lights, no hand signals, expired plates, you name it. I just happened to have the digital camera with me and the experience prompted me to carry a disposable camera in the glovebox of all my vehicles....all the time.
Accident report clearly showed I wasn't liable for the accident; kid's insurance company was progressive. The Progressive adjuster read between the lines of the report and concocted a really freaky scenario showing it was a "no fault" accident, and refused to cover the damage to my vehicle (I had liability, PIP, medical, etc. only)....My $350 winter beater was totalled.
That is....he refused to pay up until I handed him the envelope with a couple of dozen photos. The next day he showed up at the house with a release form, a $1400 check, and gave me the beater for salvage.
It doesn't matter which insurance company I sign up with as within three years they annually jack up the premium to the extent I can find significantly cheaper insurance elsewhere. GEICO has been the exception and I've held onto them for the fourth year....I can't beat what they're charging me.
Curiously, I carry full coverage in the same amounts on my '95 F-250 std cab 2wd gasser and the '02 crew cab Super Duty diesel 4x4....the '02 is approximately $100 per year cheaper to cover.
I'm sticking with the Lizard but I continue to get competitive quotes every 6 months or so. Indiana Farmers is close; the worst is American Family, and the rest fall somewhere in between.
Motorcycle insurance is what ticks me off. I'm 60 with no tickets in thirty years (Escort), the one non-chargeable accident 5 years ago, and one comprehensive claim in my lifetime (kids did $1200 in damage to my '00 C3500 dually trying to steal my CDs) 5 years ago. Everyone wants $900 or more for full coverage with beefed medical on my '01 ZX-6 Ninja.
I hate insurance but I don't cheap out on coverage....just on quotes.