I recalled seeing a similar post on powerstrokenation.com and as it turned out there was a problem with multiple replacement sensors. Kinda of odd to have more than one bad replacement but could happen especially if they're coming from low-cost countries.
Temp sensors typically are either open or shorted when they go bad. Occasionally you see one that changes value but that shouldn't be the case with yours or you would still see it register, just incorrectly. If you're familiar with using a multimeter you can put the probes across the sensor terminals (if 2 terminals) or from a single terminal to the metal sensor body. If open, you should see infinite resistance, if shorted you will see close to zero ohms resistance. Not that familiar with this specific sensor so not sure what they look like. You should be able to call the parts store or Ford and ask them what a good sensor reads at ambient temperature.
Here's that other post I found:
=============================================
southmike
Online
Village Idiot Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 1,601
Re: Does a bad Coolant temp sensor affect performance
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I broke my coolant sensor ..didn't affect anything other then a useless guage driving me crazy...I tried three different sensors from autozone or advance none worked. foolishly I assumed they were cheaper. then I gave up bought it from the dealer , it worked and was cheaper go figure .
__________________
early 99 f350 4x4 crew cab, auto.
Diy Twin tymar, TS chip, Powerslot rotors & Hawk pads, ford AIC, pmt2 pcm ..... with big fat want to list.
========================================================