i have not used this brand but I used the Herculiner brand on my 05' and it had been great. other people say that didnt like it. i think the whole key to it is taking the time to prep the bed correctly. I spent a few hours scuffing and cleaning the bed and it has been in for over 2 years now with no complaints. I also applied it twice to get a thicker coating more $$ but still chea[er than a spray-in.-cody